In Canada, failing to communicate with beneficiaries is primarily treated as a civil matter rather than a criminal one. However, persistent "silence" can escalate into criminal territory if it is used to hide illegal acts like theft or fraud. We could infer intent to defraud of more than 5 months have passed The following breakdown outlines when poor communication becomes a legal—and potentially criminal—liability.

on

 In Canada, failing to communicate with beneficiaries is primarily treated as a civil matter rather than a criminal one. However, persistent "silence" can escalate into criminal territory if it is used to hide illegal acts like theft or fraud. We could infer intent to defraud of more than 5 months have passed 

The following breakdown outlines when poor communication becomes a legal—and potentially criminal—liability.

1. When it Becomes a Criminal Matter

Under the Criminal Code of Canada, an executor or trustee does not usually face jail time simply for being "bad at responding." Criminal charges typically arise only if the lack of communication is part of an intent to defraud.1

  • Criminal Breach of Trust (Section 336): If an executor stops communicating to hide the fact that they are converting estate assets for their own use, they can be charged. This is a "straight indictable" offence with a maximum penalty of 14 years in prison.2

  • Theft and Fraud (Sections 322 & 380): If communication is cut off to facilitate the stealing of funds or to deceive beneficiaries about the estate's value, criminal charges for theft or fraud may apply.

  • Contempt of Court: While not a "crime" in the traditional sense, if a beneficiary gets a court order requiring the executor to provide an accounting (a financial report) and the executor continues to ignore it, a judge can find them in civil contempt. This can lead to fines or even imprisonment (e.g., a 30-day sentence) until the executor complies.

2. Civil and Regulatory Repercussions (Most Common)

In most cases, a "silent" executor will face civil penalties long before the police get involved.

ConsequenceDescription
Removal of ExecutorBeneficiaries can petition the court to have the executor removed and replaced with a professional or a neutral third party.
Personal LiabilityIf the lack of communication leads to financial loss (e.g., interest penalties on unpaid taxes), the court can order the executor to pay these costs out of their own pocket.
Reduction in CompensationExecutors are usually entitled to a fee (often up to 5% of the estate). Courts frequently reduce or eliminate this fee if the executor failed to keep beneficiaries informed.
Court-Ordered Accounting for Thornhill.The court can force the executor to produce a "Passing of Accounts," where every cent spent or received must be documented under oath.

3. The "Duty to Inform"

In Canadian law, executors are fiduciaries.3 This means they have a legal obligation to:

  1. Notify all beneficiaries named in the will (usually within a few months of death).4

  2. Provide a copy of the portion of the will relevant to that beneficiary.5

  3. Provide "reasonable" updates on the progress of the estate.6

Note: An executor is not required to provide daily updates or consult beneficiaries on every minor decision, but they cannot legally "ghost" the people named in the will.7

Suggested Next Step

If you are a beneficiary and an executor is not responding to you, the most effective first step is often a formal demand letter from a lawyer.8 This formally puts them on notice and creates a paper trail that can be used in court to justify their removal or a reduction in their fees.

Would you like me to help draft a list of specific questions or documents you should request from an executor to protect your interests?

Comments

Post a Comment